between the river and Route 9

Home · Moving to Middletown

Moving to Middletown, CT: A Neighborhood-by-Neighborhood Guide

By Erik Hernal, founder & editor

The best neighborhoods to move to in Middletown, CT are Downtown / Main Street (walkable, dining and bars, best for young professionals and renters), South Farms (leafy and residential, best for families), Westfield (suburban and quiet with bigger lots), and Westlake (established cluster-home community on the west side). Here's the honest pitch: you get a real downtown with genuinely good food and central-Connecticut access for prices below the state median. The catch is you'll need a car, the property taxes sting, and Route 9 still has traffic lights on it.

People move to Middletown for that mix, and most of them stay. The city was settled in 1653 (the original name was Mattabeseck, after the people who lived along the river first). In the 1700s it was one of Connecticut's busiest sailing ports, later an industrial center, and it's grown into one of the more interesting places to live in central Connecticut: a real city of about 47,000, not a bedroom suburb, with a downtown people actually use. Here's the neighborhood-by-neighborhood read from folks who live here.

What are the best neighborhoods in Middletown?

Start with what kind of life you want. Downtown Middletown is the seven-block heart of the city, a genuinely walkable downtown, loud in a good way, with restaurants and shops, coffee shops, and bars packed along Main Street and a real range of cuisines within walking distance. It's mostly apartments and historic multifamily, and it's where you land if you want to skip the car for dinner. Just south, South Farms is the easy answer for families and professionals who want a yard, historic homes, and a quiet street but still want to be five minutes from Main.

Out west, Westfield is the suburban corner, its own fire district, bigger lots, the spot for people who want space and calm. Westlake, on the western edge, has "The Farms," an award-winning cluster-home community built back in 1969, leafy and established. Highland is the only part of town Interstate 91 (I-91) actually runs through, so it's the practical pick if your commute points north or west. To the north, Newfield Heights is the more commercial stretch, where a lot of the everyday businesses and restaurants sit.

Two honest notes. The North End carries an old rough reputation, but it's genuinely on the upswing and prices reflect that. And Maromas, the southeastern corner, is industrial and mostly uninhabited (it's where Pratt & Whitney sits), so ignore any relocation blog that sells it as a rural retreat. It isn't a place you move to.

How much does it cost to live in Middletown?

For Connecticut, the cost of living in Middletown is a deal. The median home value runs roughly $300,000 to $330,000, well under the Connecticut median of about $458,000, and a good share of residents own their homes rather than rent. Rent averages in the mid-$1,700s, call it $1,720 for a one-bedroom and just under $2,000 for a two. Overall the cost of housing and living sits a bit above the national average but below the Connecticut average, which is the whole point: you get a real CT city without Glastonbury or Fairfield County money. Neighboring Cromwell and Middlefield run similar.

Working in Middletown helps the math, too. The big local employers are Middlesex Health (the old Middlesex Hospital), Pratt & Whitney, Connecticut Valley Hospital, and Wesleyan, so the median income holds up and a lot of people both live and work in town instead of commuting out.

The asterisk is taxes. Connecticut is a high-property-tax state, and Middletown's twist is fire districts: you pay the base city mill rate plus a fire-district surcharge, so most homeowners land in the mid-to-high 30s in mills depending on which district they're in. Budget for it. It still beats Hartford by a wide margin, but don't believe anyone who calls Middletown "low tax."

What's the commute like from Middletown?

Route 9 is the spine. It runs along the Connecticut River from the shoreline up to I-91 in Cromwell, and it puts the nearby cities in easy reach: Hartford in about 20 to 25 minutes and New Haven in roughly 30 to 35. The shoreline at Old Saybrook is about the same straight down Route 9.

Now the famous part: Route 9 has actual stoplights downtown, traffic signals on a highway, which is exactly as annoying as it sounds at rush hour. The state has a project to fix it, but it's not done and won't be for a few years. Plan your life around it for now.

One thing newcomers always miss: Middletown has no train station. The nearest CTrail Hartford Line stop is in Meriden, about nine miles west, with Berlin and Wallingford not far either. Public transportation in town is limited: the local bus is River Valley Transit (the old Middletown Area Transit, renamed), and it's fine for short hops but thin. Bottom line: you need a car here. Bradley Airport is about 35 to 40 minutes north, and Old Saybrook on the shoreline has the nearest Amtrak.

What are the schools like in Middletown?

Middletown Public Schools runs eight elementary schools, Beman Middle School, and the single Middletown High School. For private and parochial, the two big regional Catholic schools are right here: Xavier High School (all-boys, on Randolph Road) and its sister school Mercy High School (all-girls) a few miles away, both of which pull students from across central Connecticut.

And then there's the thing that shapes the whole town: Wesleyan University, a top-tier liberal arts school of about 3,000 undergrads, founded in 1831, right on High Street. For grown-up education and retraining, Middlesex Community College (now the Middlesex campus of CT State) sits on a hill with a river-valley view.

What's it actually like to live in Middletown?

Better than people expect. The Main Street food scene is the real draw, unusually deep for a city this size, from wood-fired pizza to a thirty-year-old vegan institution, with new restaurants and other places on Main Street opening all the time. (We keep a running guide to the best restaurants in Middletown if you want the local shortlist.)

Wesleyan is the multiplier. Its Center for the Arts runs hundreds of events a year, most of them free and open to the public, plus a film series several nights a week. It gives Middletown a progressive, arts-heavy, genuinely diverse feel you don't get in a typical Connecticut suburb. Middletown Pride is the largest Pride celebration in the state, around 20,000 people downtown on the first Saturday of June.

For the outdoors, Wadsworth Falls State Park has a real waterfall and a few miles of trails, Harbor Park puts you right on the riverfront, and there's more parks and open space per square mile than you'd guess. Kidcity Children's Museum downtown is a family-friendly lifesaver with little kids, and the historic Inn at Middletown, set in a former National Guard armory, anchors the top of Main Street. Between the food, the river, the arts, the entertainment venues, and the schools, there's genuinely something for everyone here, which is a big part of why people rate the quality of life so high.

The honest cons: you need that car, the property taxes are high even for the region, nightlife past Main Street is thin, and yes, those Route 9 lights. None of it is a dealbreaker. All of it is worth knowing before you sign a lease.

Who should move to Middletown, and who shouldn't?

Move here if you want a small city with a pulse: good food, an arts scene punching way above its weight, central-Connecticut access, and a price that doesn't require a finance salary. It's a solid area for families, and it fits young professionals, families and professionals who'd rather have character than a cul-de-sac, hospital and Pratt & Whitney workers, and Wesleyan people who came and stayed.

Skip it if you need a walk-to-the-train commute, want a manicured suburb with no rough edges, or expect a big nightlife scene. Middletown is a city, not a postcard, and that's exactly why the people who love it love it. For the right person it's a genuinely great place to live, with top-rated food, a strong sense of community, and a high quality of life for the money.

Common questions about moving to Middletown

Is Middletown, CT a good place to live? For the right person, yes. It pairs a walkable downtown and a real arts-and-food scene with central-Connecticut access and prices below the state median, which is why residents consistently rate the quality of life high. The trade-offs are the car dependence and the property taxes.

Is Middletown, CT safe? It's generally safe for a small city. Violent crime runs below the national average; property crime is the more common concern, and it varies by neighborhood, with the west side considered the safest and parts of the North End historically rougher but improving. Don't let the city's size fool you into thinking it's dangerous, the data doesn't support that.

Middletown vs. Cromwell or Middlefield? Middletown is the bigger one, with the downtown, the university, and the dining. Cromwell and Middlefield are quieter and run a little cheaper on taxes, so the call comes down to whether you want a real downtown or a calmer suburb.

Are there jobs in Middletown? Yes. Working in Middletown is realistic thanks to Middlesex Health, Pratt & Whitney, Connecticut Valley Hospital, Liberty Bank, and Wesleyan, so a good share of residents both live and work in town instead of commuting to Hartford.

New here? The fastest way to feel like a local is knowing what's on each week, and that's exactly what we do, free, every Thursday. While you settle in, our local guides to the best restaurants in Middletown, free things to do, and a perfect weekend are a good start. See what's happening right now on our events page, browse past issues, or subscribe above and we'll send the good stuff.